Skip to main content

Synology btrfs raid

Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous Mythic Path Guide

Btrfs, which can be pronounced as “Butter FS”, “Better FS”, or “B-Tree FS”, is Btrfs is a new file system for Linux, one that is still very much in development. From what I can tell, it was set up with two 8TB drives in RAID 1 (Drives A and B), with a third 8TB (Drive C) added a few months later. 14), you can look at Marc MERLIN's page about btrfs raid 5/6. org SHR vs SHR2 and ext4 vs Btrfs. Based on the diagram below, Synology has implemented the layers in between the file systems and disks to ensure that Synology has full control to achieve the Btrfs is a modern file system developed by multiple parties and now supported by select Synology NAS models. I'm using Synology DS719+ (DSM 6. (non-critical) When setting up the RAID on this Synology DS it was asking to The simple redundancy RAID levels utilize different mirrors in a way that does not achieve the maximum performance. There is also no direct "change" from EXT4 to BTRFS. 265/H. and I really want to changes to BTRFS However, it is known that Btrfs RAID is unstable and not suitable for production environments. Unfortunately Synology limit is 128TB per volume so we created two volumes, one for iSCI LUN and the other one for storing back-ups. Power up OMV and rename the Btrfs "volume" (raid appliance) from terminal using brtfs label as OMV cannot deal with blanks in the label. Select the Synology volume in the ReclaiMe window showing the available disks and partitions. Due to the Btrfs RAID issues, Synology chose Linux RAID. Next, I created a storage volume and configured the drives to use SHR (Synology Hybrid RAID) with the Btrfs file system. Now click on Apply. Btrfs combines all the devices into a storage pool first, and then duplicates the chunks as file data is created. The actual HDD size will be affected by the system partition and can vary between vendors, so the values calculated may differ from the actual results. Btrfs offers native "RAID" for #Multi-device file systems. This is also possible through metadata mirroring. Note Btrfs RAID array management is a if you're going to run btrfs in any configuration in which it manages multiple disks—as opposed to, eg. The main reason for Synology to use btrfs and not the more advanced ZFS may be not related to license issues but the fact that ZFS would require a whole new concept of appliance organisation with its integration of volume, raid and share management while btrfs offers a simple replacement option of ext4 with btrfs. The reasons were: More power; Support to run Docker; Hardware Encryption; Now, If you want to use Docker on Synology, you have to switch to the new filesystem Btrfs. Docker’s btrfs storage driver leverages many Btrfs features for image and container management. Feature marked as mostly OK for now. I have configured 1 hot spare disk. ls /dev/nvme* (Lists your NVMe drives) 2. 3. org However, most of the top tier Synology HDD NAS have the option of Btrfs as the file system. No errors found at all. This also means sharing via SAMBA or other tools will not account for RAID. When blocks are read in, checksums are verified. You want to change your current RAID setup. Note Btrfs can add and remove devices online, and freely convert between RAID levels after the FS has been created. I've just purchased a Synology DS1813 to replace my aging ReadyNAS Pro. Please go to Storage Manager > Volume for more information. I figured I would start off my Synology experience with the DSM 6 beta, so that I would be able to take advantage of BTRFS from the start and avoid a reformat down the track (the unit is to be a backup NAS anyway, so it's a minimal risk with running the beta). Unable to access to btrfs RAID 1 Disk access from Linux F. Log into your Synology DSM. Refer to the full thread at linux-btrfs (Re: using raid56 on a private machine, 2020-10-05). We’ve been looking at an issue with a two-bay Synology NAS where the second drive has been fried and the first one seems to be on the blink. Steps if you haven’t changed your DiskStation: Backup your data! If you switch to a device with new … Continue reading "How to easily migrate a Synology EXT4 volume to Btrfs without Most Synology Models allow for use of the BTRFS file system, and many users have to choose between BTRFS and EXT4 for the filesystem on their Synology. RAID 5 can afford to lose one hard drive and keep going, RAID 6 can lose two drives, and a RAID 10 NAS can lose up to half of its hard drives. BTRFS can rebalance the data chunks across all spindles. The migration also works with only one device. . There are no equivalent options for optimising earlier ext versions to raid. Will be using this Synology NAS for this purposes: - to store our Veeam backup files (critical) - small file server,so some of the Windows desktop computers can store some files. Example: A RAID10 consisting of 8x 2TB drives results in a capacity of 8 TB. synology btrfs setup txt dduper --device /dev/mapper/cachedev --dir /mnt -- analyze # copy the logs. For Synology NAS devices, look for the volume under the Linux LVM or BTRFS sections. At this point I have my 4x2TB and 1x10TB in slots. But now I still have the old EXT4 file system. realising that the sub volumes are not available and running Btrfs scrub to validate the fs as those folders/sub-volumes appeared as shown above. There is no direct migration from RAID 1 to RAID 5 (preferred over SHR, which is actually a software RAID that had some known issues especially with DSM updates, more info you may want to read the older forum posts at Synology). AFIAK, you cannot run command 12 until the resync is complete. Before I get started, I would like to ask if btrfs supports increasing raid capacity by replacing disks by bigger ones (and not adding additional disks). Storage Manager is showing that one drive is Not Initialized. BTRFS RAID is configured during or after you set up the filesystem (using btrfs-progs). SHR vs SHR2 and ext4 vs Btrfs. Destroy /volume2 and add the remaining disks to /volume1. Synology Knowledge Center provides you with answers to frequently asked questions, troubleshooting steps, software tutorials, and all the technical documentation you may need. Synology Hybrid RAID or SHR, has been around for quite a while now, and though it has not made the big impact that Synology NAS’ Btrfs file system has, it is still an increasingly popular choice for many when it comes to protecting their hardware and their data in a Hard Drive Enclosure. The mount command for ext4 has the "stripe" option. However, it is known that Btrfs RAID is unstable and not suitable for production environments. Utilities such as the regular df command or btrfs fi show do not take RAID settings into account, as that is done by btrfs itself. Got a new Synology DS and setting up . BTRFS is just used as a file system on top of the MDADM RAID implementation, so BTRFS doesn't have anything to do with the management of the disks and the RAID arrays on them See full list on kb. As for the QNAP, it does not use Btfrs as the file system but offers ZFS on its advanced equipment, rack-mounted. 5. RAID - support for software-based RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 10 Self-healing - checksums for data and metadata, automatic detection of silent data corruptions Development of Btrfs started in 2007. Btrfs supports RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 10, RAID 5 and RAID 6 (but see the section below about RAID 5/6), and it can also duplicate metadata or data on a single spindle or multiple disks. Setting up or changing a RAID setup isn't difficult, you just have to know how it works. So you can run command 11 every few minutes or so to see when it is complete before formatting the partition in btrfs *** 1. You can mount one of those snapshots with the mount If you have a Synology NAS that supports BTRFS (mostly the intel based NASes) and that you decided to use BTRFS, there are a couple of shared folders automatically created for you (like the “homes” or “video”) but they don’t have the “compression” option set, and trying to edit the shared folder in the administration GUI does not help, the check box is grayed out, meaning it is *** Command 10 builds the RAID array and it took about 20 minutes to build a 500GB RAID 1 array on my system. So I wrote down both ways. The file system checks these checksums every time it is read and when it detects a mismatch, it can automatically detect and repair corrupted files using supported RAID volumes, including RAID configurations 1, 5, 6, 10, F1, SHR. The DS1019+ needed more than 12 hours to verify the hard drives, configure Synology Hybrid RAID: peculiarities of data organization and its recovery. Synology most likely uses MD-RAID 5 or 6 and then put BTRFS on top of it. RAID. For Synology NAS, you create your RAIDs (1,5,6,10 SHR-1, SHR-2). Then once you start running out of storage space, you can simply expand the RAID pool on your Synology NAS by adding additional drives to your RAID pool. Defragment your Synology BTRFS Volume and improve performance! In the process of optimizing a Synology DS1815+ for iSCSI, I opted to defragment the volume containing the LUN. (non-critical) When setting up the RAID on this Synology DS it was asking to Btrfs can add and remove devices online, and freely convert between RAID levels after the FS has been created. I was wondering a few things: - What is the performance impact (compared to it being disabled - aka "regular old cache") - this might require testing of certain specific workloads* - How does this scale as you add more storage? This is a significant difference: The Ext4 file system supports journaling, while Btrfs has a copy-on-write (CoW) feature. 264 4K video transcoding provides hassle-free and high-quality video playback among various devices. If you'd like to learn btrfs raid5/6 and rebuilds by example (based on kernel 3. just bought DiskStation DS218+ and there is btrfs pre installed. On 01 Aug 2017 a RFC patch to fix write hole was posted in the mailing list: Btrfs: Add journal for raid5/6 writes. Wait until the ReclaiMe File Recovery starts to bring files and then check the quality of the recovery using the Preview . Then you can use ext4 or Btrfs as the file system. 12, namely scrub and auto-repair fixes. All others should stick to a RAID 10 configuration for now. Btrfs is a next generation copy-on-write filesystem that supports many advanced storage technologies that make it a good fit for Docker. After each disk replacement, a rebuild / rebalance is executed. Open Storage Manager (found under the “Start Menu”) then click on Volume > Manage. The following diagram explains the concept where Synology implements the "Device Mapper" and "RAID" layers to replace the original Btrfs RAID to ensure full control over communication with the highest stability. This is the number of data disks times the number of blocks per chunk, ie the size of a stripe in disk blocks. 2. Then, each 2TB drive gets replaced by a 6 TB drive. I believe these were BTRFS drives set up in a 'mdadm' Linux raid. Open an SSH connection to the Synology NAS, and issue the following command: However, Synology NAS can also use BTRFS as the default file system, which supports background data consistency checks to speed up RAID creation and recovery. (with the exspansion unit) The RAID is configured in level 6 with two volumes Btrfs. If you have a Synology NAS that supports BTRFS (mostly the intel based NASes) and that you decided to use BTRFS, there are a couple of shared folders automatically created for you (like the “homes” or “video”) but they don’t have the “compression” option set, and trying to edit the shared folder in the administration GUI does not help, the check box is grayed out, meaning it is 2015 - Made the switch from hardware RAID to Btrfs; 2016 - Btrfs RAID 6 was already considered experimental, but was called out as dangerous and likely to corrupt data in several scenarios. In th How to defrag Synology NAS using BTRFS. (NOTE this is NOT BTRFS RAID but rather "plain" RAID with BTRFS on top for benefits like check-summing / snapshotting etc) volume 1 on has crashed, it is possible that more files may be corrupted under this circumstance. I had a hot spare in my 5 drive NAS so I removed it to make a spare slot. Distribution of one file system to several devices. That's completely different. NAS Brands in 2021 – Which One Should You Choose? https://nascompares. The release of less expensive NAS models along with the introduction of SHR in 2010 has contributed to the increasing popularity of Synology among home users and small businesses who became able to effectively store and share digital content without the need for thorough planning, performing any calculations or delving RAID. In this scenario, with the sequential I/O turned off Join Now. BtrFS has a software RAID layer in it. In this article, we highlight 3 different options: You want to create a new RAID setup (Note: files will be deleted). The file system is BTRFS. Download and launch ReclaiMe File Recovery software. Hello! I just wanted to share a quick video idea; With DSM 7. Wait till the software starts bringing data. Recover Btrfs files in automatic mode. The fact that a hard disk drive has been taken offline does not necessarily mean the hard disk drive has broken. On top of that I used btrfs, a Copy-On-Write (COW) modern filesystem that is supposed to solve all kind of issues with respect to pooling, snapshots, … If your Btrfs filesystem is on a MD software RAID device created by Linux, you will also need WinMD to get this to appear under Windows. See the Btrfs wiki page for more information. Today at work we found out our Synology box had its motherboard go. Btrfs: Next Generation Storage When dealing with large-scale data storage, businesses require a solution that prevents data corruption, while providing flexible backup tools. Oct 09, 2020 I followed the guide on Synology website https: The third aspect of QNAP vs Synology is the SHR and RAID configuration options . When running data scrubbing on a Btrfs volume, file system data scrubbing will be performed first to make sure the data is accurate. Perfect time to change the file system – the DS215play didn’t support Btrfs. Began phase out of 3 TB drives. We have a Synology RS3617xs rack model with 24 x 8TB drives installed. Now, all my data is effectively stored on the first 2 disks in the new volume. synology. My configuration was pretty standard - 4 disks in a Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR), a variant of RAID 5 which allowed for easy resizing of the RAID array when bigger disks are inserted. For btrfs data (-d flag), experimentation with raid5 and raid6 is encouraged by users who are willing to tolerate the occasional manual intervention and to report bugs/experiences to upstream. These tools only show the total amount allocated by btrfs on the disks, they don't know what format btrfs is using for the data. Setting up in RAID10. Synology got around this by using MDADM to handle the raid portion. Btrfs supports RAID-0, RAID-1, and RAID-10. So I thought it's a good idea to move to EXT4. So, Btrfs has built-in RAID support and therefore this feature is inherent in it. . Btrfs is a modern file system developed by multiple parties and now supported by select Synology NAS models. After five years I decided to replace my Synology DS213air with a new Synology DS718+. Since that time, Btrfs is a part of the Linux kernel and is under active development. Note that ReclaiMe is designed to bring data earlier into the scan • Internal: Btrfs, ext4 • External: Btrfs, ext4, ext3, FAT, NTFS, HFS+, exFAT4 Supported RAID type Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR), Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 5, RAID 6, RAID 10 Storage management • Maximum single volume size: 108TB • Maximum of system snapshots: 65,5365 • Maximum internal volumes: 512 SSD cache The simple redundancy RAID levels utilize different mirrors in a way that does not achieve the maximum performance. Btrfs was designed to address obstacles often encountered in enterprise storage systems, such as fault tolerance, management, and data protection. It has 10TB x 5 drives. The next-generation Btrfs file system brings these tools to Synology NAS servers, allowing businesses and organizations to reduce maintenance overhead and efficiently DS218+ integrates the Btrfs file system, delivering the most advanced storage technology to meet the management needs of small businesses. File system defragmentation can Migrating the old drives over from the old DS411j went without a glitch. The Btrfs sysadmin page also has a section with some more technical background. I will be using this mostly for my small business , but will also be using this partially for personal /home storage . In this tutorial we are going to cover how to expand a RAID Pool on Synology NAS by adding an additional drive to it, as well some important things to know before you expand your pool! Join Now. Synology’s Data Scrubbing 2 integrates Btrfs data scrubbing and RAID scrubbing to ensure data integrity. The diagram below illustrates how Btrfs RAID takes over the entire communication between the Btrfs file system layer and the disks. Synology get a bit fancy with their SHR as they use LVM (At least to the best of my memory it is LVM) for creating the RAID array, and layer BTRFS on top of that volume instead of relying on BTRFS for the RAID array so they avoid the data corruption problems BTRFS is well known for with RAID arrays. For this reason, Synology chose Linux RAID over Btrfs RAID. Ferdinando @ferdytao. com/2021/01/01/nas-buyers-guide-2021-get-it-right-first-time/Buying your first Network Copy all data from /volume2 (RAID-0) to /volume1 (BTRFS), and verify. Although I wouldn't exactly describe it as "experimental" any more, it is, as stated in the Wiki at kernel. That command would look like this: sudo btrfs send / mnt / btrfs / backups / ro-snapshot / | btrfs receive / mnt / btrfs-send-test /. Switched to RAID 1. Next select Start file system defragmentation and click on Next. Copy everything from Volume1 to Volume2. 2017 - Dropped from 6 to 5 disks on primary Btrfs array and replaced all 3s with 6s. For the btrfs-based NASes like NETGEAR, the volume will be under the BTRFS section; for other NASes, look for it under the Linux md-raid or Linux LVM section. On the disks is a BTRFS filesystem with metadata set as RAID1 and data as . I recently purchased a Synology DS1618+ and have three 6TB Seagate Ironwolf Pro drives arriving soon as well. Synology might choose to use BtrFS or MD for their RAID when BtrFS is used for the FS, I'm not sure which they use. Use the BTRFS storage driver. I was wondering a few things: - What is the performance impact (compared to it being disabled - aka "regular old cache") - this might require testing of certain specific workloads* - How does this scale as you add more storage? 2. Lokking at the comments in the web it seems to be not stable (?) and also DropBox won't continue to support btrfs. 4K Ultra HD video transcoding DiskStation’s real-time H. 9, btrfs also supports RAID-5 and RAID-6 although that code is still experimental. 0, SSD Cache BTRFS metadata pinning was added. The OP claimed that BtrFS was doing his RAID. Synology RAID Calculator offers you an estimate on the space utilization with various mixed HDD configurations and RAID types. This Synology had 2x Samsung 850 Pro SSDs in RAID-0 serving a cache, but the cache will be skipped for sequential I/O. Synology Hybrid RAID: peculiarities of data organization and its recovery. *** Command 10 builds the RAID array and it took about 20 minutes to build a 500GB RAID 1 array on my system. It is similar *** Command 10 builds the RAID array and it took about 20 minutes to build a 500GB RAID 1 array on my system. This feature allows for increased capacity and reliability. EXT . com Synology adopts Linux RAID instead of Btrfs RAID to ensure the RAID implementation is most stable and suitable for business use. As of Linux 3. 2015 - Made the switch from hardware RAID to Btrfs; 2016 - Btrfs RAID 6 was already considered experimental, but was called out as dangerous and likely to corrupt data in several scenarios. Please refer to Synology Storage Manager for precise data just bought DiskStation DS218+ and there is btrfs pre installed. The logic can be improved so the reads will spread over the mirrors evenly or based on device congestion. I got that part from the OP. RAID56 . See also Quibble , an experimental bootloader allowing Windows to boot from Btrfs, and Ntfs2btrfs , a tool which allows in-place conversion of NTFS filesystems. Some fixes went to 4. What is the RAID implementation for Btrfs File System on Synology NAS? Synology adopts Linux RAID instead of Btrfs RAID to ensure the RAID implementation is most stable and suitable for business use. Today I switched from a Synology DS215play to a DS918+. Make a new Volume with the newer Btrfs file system to get snapshots, self-healing, and better mirroring. We’ve removed the first drive from the Synology and plugged it into a PC running an Ubuntu Live CD to try to recover the data. Mdadm comparison, the dual-HDD Btrfs RAID benchmarks, and four-SSD RAID 0/1/5/6/10 Btrfs benchmarks are RAID Linux benchmarks on these four Intel SATA 3. 2-23739) with DX513 Expansion, which is populated with 5x 10TB IronWolfs having 1 Volume of SHR (1-drive failure tolerance, BTRFS) beyond separate volume, on two disks on main device (DS). Be warned - parity raid in btrfs is apparently still experimental (2018) and prone to eat data. 18. Synology Hybrid RAID, Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 5, RAID 6, RAID 10 Note the 416play 4 Bay model supports BTRFS despite not being a + model. Following the recent Btrfs RAID: Native vs. Featuring all the functionality of EXT 4, it also supports background data integrity checks (without affecting system performance when conducting them) and much faster RAID building and re-building times. Notable features which set btrfs RAID apart from mdadm are self-healing redundant arrays and online balancing. , Synology and Netgear NAS devices, Phoronix: Btrfs RAID 5/6 Code Found To Be Very Unsafe & Will Likely Require A Rewrite It turns out the RAID5 and RAID6 code for the Btrfs file-system's built-in RAID support is faulty and users should not be making use of it if you care about your data Btrfs. 1) He formatted his 4TB red drive to btrfs. The following diagram explains the concept - Synology has implemented the layers in between to ensure that we have full control of the communication for the highest stability. Select the NAS volume you need to recover and click Start. Advanced Btrfs file system offering 65000 system-wide snapshots and 1024 snapshots per shared folder Synology Hybrid RAID, Basic, JBOD, RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 5 *** Command 10 builds the RAID array and it took about 20 minutes to build a 500GB RAID 1 array on my system. 4. The third aspect of QNAP vs Synology is the SHR and RAID configuration options . This is great if you have a Btrfs device on a NAS or a RAID array in your system and want to take a snapshot of your operating system and send it over there. 0 solid state drives using other file-systems -- including EXT4, XFS, and Btrfs with Linux 3. How to convert btrfs to EXT4 and have RAID 1 afterwards again? I have no seperate Linux system to format the disk. Both NAS and DAS utilise RAID as a form of protection Btrfs is a modern file system developed by multiple parties and now supported by select Synology NAS models. Use a spare slot and add one drive. Btrfs is included in the mainline Linux kernel. The release of less expensive NAS models along with the introduction of SHR in 2010 has contributed to the increasing popularity of Synology among home users and small businesses who became able to effectively store and share digital content without the need for thorough planning, performing any calculations or delving Btrfs. Recovering a Synology SHR-RAID 1 array with only one disk. RAID-1 is defined currently as "2 copies of all the data on different devices". You want to restore your old RAID setup (Note: files will be deleted). Notice: File system defragmentation is available on specific models only. Synology Hybrid RAID or SHR, has been around for quite a while now, and though it has not make the big impact that Synology NAS’ Btrfs file system has, it is still an increasing popular choice for many when it comes to protecting their hardware and their data in a Hard Drive enclosure.